11/16/2025
Liam’s Apple, Almond, and Maple Crumble Loaf
Signature Bake, Collection 5, Episode 1 Cake Week
What is a Bramley apple? I have never seen them in any orchard or store produce section in my area. Apparently, they are an English cultivar that are very crisp and tart and usually used in baking. The best substitute in the US would be Granny Smith apples. I made this cake during the start of apple season so I used fresh Macs bought at my local apple orchard. Very fresh Macs will be tart and crisp, but they get soft after a week or two so most store bought ones would not be good in this recipe. If it is not apple season, I would go with Granny Smith.
Notes from the bake: I ordered light muscovado sugar from Amazon and used it in this recipe. It is comparable to light brown sugar, just a touch drier and maybe a bit less sweet. I think there is not enough difference to go out of the way to get muscovado.
I bought some whole nutmeg at a local co-op and highly recommend grating it yourself. My nutmeg grater is one of my favorite baking tools.
For golden caster sugar I used Domino’s Golden Sugar. Once again, it is not as finely ground as caster sugar would be, but it works. I imagine I could throw it in my food processor for a few seconds to make it finer–I am not sure it would make a big difference.
This recipe uses maple syrup– I used my homemade syrup from last season’s sugaring. I always recommend using real maple syrup, not imitation. It is worth every penny.
This was baked in an 8X4 loaf tin. The instructions said to grease and line the base and short ends of the tin with baking paper. My cake stuck a bit on the long sides of the tin. Maybe lining the whole tin with baking paper would work better?
Judge’s reactions:
Interestingly, the judges on GBBO thought Liam’s bake was stodgy (Prue) and a bit boring (Paul). My judges disagreed. This cake was moist, full of apple flavor, and the crumble top and glaze were delicious. I cut it while still a touch warm and Joey and I each had a slice with our mugs of tea. The kitchen smelled so wonderful, we just couldn’t wait for it to cool. We should have waited. It was even better once cooled, and best of all after a day of resting and letting the flavors develop and the moistness intensify. So we recommend letting the cake completely cool, wrapping it up in plastic wrap, and serving it the next day.
This cake was completely gone the day after baking it.