Butcher Boy Mt. Sinai

09/27/2025

Prime Rib - cut to order as steaks or roast.

We’re also making stuffed chicken breasts today.

Call us to get your order ready.
631-473-1214

11/25/2024

We’re getting ready to have all your Thanksgiving orders ready! Make sure you have your order placed. All orders should be picked up by Wednesday at 2pm.

Happy Thanksgiving

06/17/2024

A chuck filet steak - one to feed your whole family.

06/14/2024

Father’s Day weekend is here and we have everything you need to spoil dad with the best. From our dry aged USDA prime porter house and rib eye steaks, to our famous chicken burgers, ribs, chicken skewers, tomahawk steaks, heroes, and so much more.

Call ahead to place your order or come visit us and see what looks good to you. We will have fresh vegetables and our delicious salads for your sides as well.

631-473-1214
41 Route 25A
Mt. Sinai, NY 11766

05/30/2024

USDA stamped prime shell steak with the most beautiful marbleization.

05/27/2024

During Memorial Day we honor those who gave the ultimate sacrifice for our freedom. Their dedication and sacrifice will always be remembered. 🇺🇸

The store will be open today until 2pm but will be closed early in honor of the holiday.

I hope you all have the opportunity today and this weekend to spend this time with your family and friends to remember and reflect on those fallen soldiers who have served our country with honor and also to keep in your hearts their families who will forever mourn their loss.

05/25/2024

When we were designed a new sign for the store a few months back we really thought about it. We thought about all the years of history this store has. About all the years of loyal customers who have come to the store to feed their family.

Butcher Boy has been a family business since 1957 and so much of the history can still be seen right here in the store. So we kept the “boy” who can be seen in some of the old wooden signs we still have that were made by a customer of the store years ago. And after some recent renovations those signs are proudly hanging back up next to the new sign. Because new never means forgetting or getting rid of the old.

We’re so proud of this store’s history and we’re so proud to continue its legacy of great service and great food.

05/24/2024

The long weekend is here, the weather is calling for sunshine and warm temperatures.

Stop in for all your grilling and BBQ needs. We have you covered from the big steaks, to chicken sticks, vegetables, even s’mores kits!

See you at 41 Route 25A in Mt. Sinai

Call in and we can get your order ready for you for in advance to save time.

05/17/2024

What’s for dinner this weekend?

Stop by Butcher Boy for top quality steak, chicken, burgers and more! We have you covered for all your weekend and week day meal planning needs.

41 Route 25A
Mt. Sinai, NY 11766

05/06/2024

Mother’s Day is coming! Be prepared with the best.

Start her day with flowers and fresh slab bacon. End it with a beautifully grilled steak.

Whatever her favorite cut of meat be sure she doesn’t have to worry about a thing. Call ahead and order today and we will be sure it’s all ready for you.

631-473-1214
41 Route 25A
Mt. Sinai, NY 11766

05/02/2024

It shatters our hearts to hear of a child or a family with a child who suffers. We pray for this family to find a health, peace, and support in this time.

Sweet baby Juliette was diagnosed with a Brain Tumor and has to have immediate surgery to r… Karly Srica needs your support for Please help Juliette Tomanelli