Fish Tales Market and Eatery

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Fish Tales Market and Eatery Welcome to Fish Tales Market and Eatery in Marathon, a “local’s favorite” where you will find fresh Seafood, Fish & Steaks, plus homecooked meals.

Fish Tales is the oldest Fish Market & Restaurant in Marathon. Locally, family & veteran owned. take out and curbside pickup available

11/13/2026

COME HAVE DINNER WITH US @ FISH TALES OR CALL IN YOUR TO-GO ORDER!

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

CHICKEN WINGS (10) BBQ, HOT, Siraracha Honey or Garlic Chili $12.95
1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95
DUCK WONTONS (Duck, Cream Cheese & Corn) $14.95
SHIITAKE MUSHROOM POTSTICKERS W/ SESAME SOY SAUCE $9.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR APPETIZER $14.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES W/ SIDE OF JOHNNY SAUCE $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER SPLIT PEA & HAM

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS BLACK BEANS & RICE APPLE SAUCE

DINNER SPECIALS
LARGE OR JUMBO STONE CRAB CLAWS - MKT PRICE

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

FRIED ALLIGATOR PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

GRILLED OR BLACKENED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

STUFFED CABBAGE ROLL WITH MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95
FRIED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

PORK SCHNITZEL W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS$18.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $23.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR OATMEAL ISLAND COOKIE SMORES COOKIE SAMOA COOKIE
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE BROWNIE

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR TOPPED W/ VANILLA ICE CREAM
CREAM CHEESE PUMPKIN ROLL
KENTUCKY BOURBON PECAN PIE
TRADITIONAL CINNAMON BUN
CHOCOLATE LAVA CAKE A’LA MODE
APPLE DUMPLING A’LA MODE
JOHNNY’S KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
ICE CREAM MUD PIE ON AN OREO CRUST – CHOCOLATE CHIP

GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY
MOSCATO CABERNET RIESLING

SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE-
NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE–
COCONUT KEY LIME ALE- SWEET WATER HAZY IPA- FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA
SIERRA NEVADA TRIPLE TORPEDO IPA – IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE

11/13/2026

CRAVING SOMETHING FRESH & DELICIOUS FOR LUNCH? SWING BY FISH TALES TODAY FOR OUR DAILY LUNCH SPECIALS! GRAB A SEAT, ENJOY GREAT FOOD, AND LET US TAKE CARE OF THE REST... SEE YOU SOON! 😎

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

CHICKEN WINGS (10) BBQ, HOT, Siraracha Honey or Garlic Chili $12.95
1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR APPETIZER $14.95
DUCK WONTONS (Duck, Cream Cheese & Corn WONTON) $14.95
SHIITAKE MUSHROOM POTSTICKERS W/ SESAME SOY SAUCE $9.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES W/ SIDE OF JOHNNY SAUCE $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER SPLIT PEA & HAM

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS BLACK BEANS & RICE APPLE SAUCE

Lunch Specials
LARGE OR JUMBO STONE CRAB CLAWS – MARKET PRICE

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

GRILLED OR BLACKENED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

STUFFED CABBAGE ROLLS WITH MASHED POTATOES & RED GRAVY $16.95

PORK SCHNITZEL W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS$18.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

CUP OF SOUP & SANDWICH – GRILLED HAM & CHEESE ON WHITE ON RYE OR WHITE BREAD $15.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95
HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $23.95

FRIED ALLIGATOR PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR SAMOA COOKIE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
SMORES COOKIE OR CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE BROWNIE

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR TOPPED W/ VANILLA ICE CREAM
CREAM CHEESE PUMPKIN ROLL
KENTUCKY BOURBON PECAN PIE
TRADITIONAL CINNAMON BUN
CHOCOLATE LAVA CAKE A’LA MODE
JOHNNY’S KEY LIME PIE
APPLE DUMPLING A’LA MODE
HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
ICE CREAM MUD PIE ON AN OREO CRUST – CHOCOLATE CHIP

GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling

PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY
MOSCATO CABERNET RIESLING

SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE-
NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE–
COCONUT KEY LIME ALE- SWEET WATER HAZY IPA- FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA
SIERRA NEVADA TRIPLE TORPEDO IPA – IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE

🎉Friday! Stop by the local Market for your steaks, seafood & fish🥩🦀🐟
11/13/2026

🎉Friday! Stop by the local Market for your steaks, seafood & fish🥩🦀🐟

11/12/2026

FISH TALES DINNER SPECIALS FOR THURSDAY😊

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

CHICKEN WINGS (10) BBQ, HOT, Siraracha Honey or Garlic Chili $12.95
1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95
DUCK WONTONS (Duck, Cream Cheese & Corn) $14.95
SHIITAKE MUSHROOM POTSTICKERS W/ SESAME SAUCE $9.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR APPETIZER $14.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES W/ SIDE OF JOHNNY SAUCE $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95
MEDIUM STONE CRAB CLAWS 5 FOR $20.00

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER SPLIT PEA & HAM

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS BLACK BEANS & RICE APPLE SAUCE

DINNER SPECIALS
LARGE OR JUMBO STONE CRAB CLAWS - MKT PRICE

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

FRIED ALLIGATOR PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

MEATLOAF WITH MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

GRILLED OR BLACKENED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED GREEN TOMATO SNAPPER PLATTER & CHOICE OF SIDE $24.95
(Fried Snapper Topped W/ Fried Green Tomato & Our Johnny Sauce)

FRIED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

PORK SCHNITZEL W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS$18.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $23.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR SAMOA COOKIE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
SMORES COOKIE OR CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE BROWNIE

PIECAKEN – 3 LAYER DESSERT – Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie & Spice Cake
PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR TOPPED W/ VANILLA ICE CREAM
CREAM CHEESE PUMPKIN ROLL
KENTUCKY BOURBON PECAN PIE
TRADITIONAL CINNAMON BUN
APPLE DUMPLING A’LA MODE
JOHNNY’S KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
ICE CREAM MUD PIE ON AN OREO CRUST – CHOCOLATE CHIP
GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest
B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling
PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY
MOSCATO CABERNET RIESLING
SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE-
NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE–
COCONUT KEY LIME ALE- SWEET WATER HAZY IPA- FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA
SIERRA NEVADA TRIPLE TORPEDO IPA – IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE

Teter and Fish are ready for Thanksgiving🦃 and the cold front❄️😂
11/12/2026

Teter and Fish are ready for Thanksgiving🦃 and the cold front❄️😂

11/12/2026

IT'S A GOOD DAY FOR LUNCH @ FISH TALES😊

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

CHICKEN WINGS (10) BBQ, HOT, Siraracha Honey or Garlic Chili $12.95
1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR APPETIZER $14.95
DUCK WONTONS (Duck, Cream Cheese & Corn WONTON) $14.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES W/ SIDE OF JOHNNY SAUCE $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95
MEDIUM STONE CRAB CLAWS 5 FOR $20.00

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER SPLIT PEA & HAM

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS BLACK BEANS & RICE APPLE SAUCE

Lunch Specials
LARGE OR JUMBO STONE CRAB CLAWS – MARKET PRICE

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

GRILLED OR BLACKENED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

MEATLOAF WITH MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95

PORK SCHNITZEL W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS$18.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

CUP OF SOUP & SANDWICH – GRILLED HAM & CHEESE ON WHITE ON RYE OR WHITE BREAD $15.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATO SNAPPER SANDWICH & CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95
(Fried Snapper Topped W/ Fried Green Tomato & Our Johnny Sauce)

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $23.95

FRIED ALLIGATOR PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR SAMOA COOKIE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
SMORES COOKIE OR CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE BROWNIE

PIECAKEN – 3 LAYER DESSERT – Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie & Spice Cake
PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR TOPPED W/ VANILLA ICE CREAM
CREAM CHEESE PUMPKIN ROLL
STRAWBERRY RHUBARB PIE
KENTUCKY BOURBON PECAN PIE
TRADITIONAL CINNAMON BUN
APPLE DUMPLING A’LA MODE
JOHNNY’S KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
ICE CREAM MUD PIE ON AN OREO CRUST – CHOCOLATE CHIP

GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest
B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling
PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY
MOSCATO CABERNET RIESLING
SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE-
NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE–
COCONUT KEY LIME ALE- SWEET WATER HAZY IPA- FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA
SIERRA NEVADA TRIPLE TORPEDO IPA – IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE

😎 The Thanksgiving In The Keys Diet would not be complete without ordering one of our amazing desserts for your Thanksgi...
11/12/2026

😎 The Thanksgiving In The Keys Diet would not be complete without ordering one of our amazing desserts for your Thanksgiving Feast.

Carrot cake
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Pumpkin Blondie Brownies
Pumpkin Rolls
German Chocolate Cake
Peanut Butter Pies
Ice Cream Pies-Assorted Flavors
Key Lime Pie
Pecan Pie
Assorted Cookies

11/11/2026

🚨DINNER SPECIALS FOR WEDNESDAY😎

COME SEE US OR CALL IN YOUR TO-GO ORDER!

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

CHICKEN WINGS (10) BBQ, HOT, Siraracha Honey or Garlic Chili $12.95
1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95
DUCK WONTONS (Duck, Cream Cheese & Corn) $14.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR APPETIZER $14.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES W/ SIDE OF JOHNNY SAUCE $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95
MEDIUM STONE CRAB CLAWS 5 FOR $20.00

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER SPLIT PEA & HAM

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS BLACK BEANS & RICE APPLE SAUCE

DINNER SPECIALS
LARGE OR JUMBO STONE CRAB CLAWS - MKT PRICE

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

FRIED ALLIGATOR PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

MEATLOAF WITH MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

GRILLED OR BLACKENED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED GREEN TOMATO SNAPPER PLATTER & CHOICE OF SIDE $24.95
(Fried Snapper Topped W/ Fried Green Tomato & Our Johnny Sauce)

FRIED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

PORK SCHNITZEL W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS$18.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $23.95

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR SAMOA COOKIE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
SMORES COOKIE OR CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE BROWNIE

PIECAKEN – 3 LAYER DESSERT – Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie & Spice Cake
PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR TOPPED W/ VANILLA ICE CREAM
CREAM CHEESE PUMPKIN ROLL
STRAWBERRY RHUBARB PIE
KENTUCKY BOURBON PECAN PIE
TRADITIONAL CINNAMON BUN
APPLE DUMPLING A’LA MODE
JOHNNY’S KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
ICE CREAM MUD PIE ON AN OREO CRUST – CHOCOLATE CHIP
GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest
B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling
PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY
MOSCATO CABERNET RIESLING
SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE-
NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE–
COCONUT KEY LIME ALE- SWEET WATER HAZY IPA- FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA

Call now to connect with business.

11/11/2026

😊TRYING TO DECIDE WHAT TO HAVE FOR LUNCH TODAY? CHECK OUT OUR AMAZING LUNCH AND DESSERTS MENU👀

FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE

CHICKEN WINGS (10) BBQ, HOT, Siraracha Honey or Garlic Chili $12.95
1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR APPETIZER $14.95
DUCK WONTONS (Duck, Cream Cheese & Corn WONTON) $14.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES W/ SIDE OF JOHNNY SAUCE $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95
MEDIUM STONE CRAB CLAWS 5 FOR $20.00

HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER
CRAWDAD CHOWDER SPLIT PEA & HAM

SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS BLACK BEANS & RICE APPLE SAUCE

Lunch Specials
LARGE OR JUMBO STONE CRAB CLAWS – MARKET PRICE

SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95

GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

GRILLED OR BLACKENED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

MEATLOAF WITH MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS $18.95

PORK SCHNITZEL W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS$18.95

WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95

JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95

CUP OF SOUP & SANDWICH – GRILLED HAM & CHEESE ON WHITE ON RYE OR WHITE BREAD $15.95

HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95
FRIED GREEN TOMATO SNAPPER SANDWICH & CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95
(Fried Snapper Topped W/ Fried Green Tomato & Our Johnny Sauce)

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese

HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95

OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $23.95

FRIED ALLIGATOR PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95

FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95

PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR SAMOA COOKIE CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
SMORES COOKIE OR CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE BROWNIE

PIECAKEN – 3 LAYER DESSERT – Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie & Spice Cake
PUMPKIN BLONDIE BAR TOPPED W/ VANILLA ICE CREAM
CREAM CHEESE PUMPKIN ROLL
STRAWBERRY RHUBARB PIE
KENTUCKY BOURBON PECAN PIE
TRADITIONAL CINNAMON BUN
APPLE DUMPLING A’LA MODE
JOHNNY’S KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
ICE CREAM MUD PIE ON AN OREO CRUST – CHOCOLATE CHIP

GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest
B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling
PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY
MOSCATO CABERNET RIESLING
SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE-
NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE–
COCONUT KEY LIME ALE- SWEET WATER HAZY IPA- FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA
SIERRA NEVADA TRIPLE TORPEDO IPA – IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE

Call now to connect with business.

Address

11711 Overseas Highway
Marathon, FL
33050

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 7:30pm
Tuesday 11am - 7:30pm
Wednesday 11am - 7:30pm
Thursday 11am - 7:30pm
Friday 11am - 7:30pm
Saturday 11am - 3pm

Telephone

+13057439196

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Fish Tales Market and Eatery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Fish Tales Market and Eatery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby grocery stores