Smithville Peanut Butter Company

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Smithville Peanut Butter Company Freshly grounded Peanut Butter in many flavors along with handmade treats and baked goods from our bakery.

🍯🥜 All the peanut butter flavor you love!Introducing our Powdered Honey Roast Peanut Butter! 💛Sweet, nutty, and packed w...
11/10/2026

🍯🥜 All the peanut butter flavor you love!

Introducing our Powdered Honey Roast Peanut Butter! 💛

Sweet, nutty, and packed with delicious honey-roasted flavor!

✨ High in protein
✨ Less fat than traditional peanut butter
✨ Made in the USA 🇺🇸
✨ Perfect for smoothies, oatmeal, baking, and more!

Enjoy the delicious taste of honey-roasted peanut butter in a versatile powder!

🥜 A little sweetness in every scoop!

4 packs are back! Hurry in before they sell out 🤗
11/06/2026

4 packs are back! Hurry in before they sell out 🤗

We’ve brought back three of our 2026 Small Batch Peanut Butter flavors for one final time, and added a favorite from 2025, together in a four pack! These flavors were very popular, so this limited edition release will not be around forever.

🍌 Choc Covered Banana, our first small batch of 2026, is the classic flavor of our Choc Choc Peanut Butter, which is a decadent duo of rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter, with the sweetness of ripe bananas.

🟤 Root B**r Float, our second small batch of 2026, is our Natural Peanut Butter blended with the smooth, sweet flavor of classic root b**r for a one-of-a-kind treat. Inspired by the timeless soda fountain favorite, this small batch captures the creamy, refreshing essence of a root b**r float.

🎂 Birthday Cake, our third small batch of 2026, is our Honey Roast Peanut Butter with sweet birthday cake flavor added. It's rich, tasty, nostalgic, and made to make every spoonful feel like a celebration.

🍏 Apple Streusel, a returning favorite from 2025, brings the taste of a cozy autumn morning to your spoon, capturing the comforting sweetness of a fresh-baked streusel.

The Four Pack is available now in the shop or online at capeislandfoods.com/product/2026-small-batch-peanut-butter-four-pack/5DJFZL2HM5SVI3JT7YEEKR4R.

🍫🥜 GO BIG OR GO HOME! 🥜🍫Calling all chocolate and peanut butter lovers! 😍Our COLOSSAL PEANUT BUTTER CUP is a chocolate l...
11/03/2026

🍫🥜 GO BIG OR GO HOME! 🥜🍫

Calling all chocolate and peanut butter lovers! 😍

Our COLOSSAL PEANUT BUTTER CUP is a chocolate lover’s dream come true!

Rich, creamy peanut butter meets delicious milk chocolate in one GIANT, irresistible treat! 🤎

Because sometimes a regular peanut butter cup just isn’t enough! 🤤

Who would you share this colossal treat with? Or are you keeping it all to yourself? 👀😂

🥓🥜 BACON + PEANUT BUTTER = A MATCH MADE IN HEAVEN! 🤤Sweet, salty, savory, and absolutely delicious!If you love bacon and...
10/28/2026

🥓🥜 BACON + PEANUT BUTTER = A MATCH MADE IN HEAVEN! 🤤

Sweet, salty, savory, and absolutely delicious!

If you love bacon and peanut butter, why not have the best of both worlds? 😍

🥓 Packed with bacon flavor
🥜 Creamy peanut butter goodness
❤️ The perfect sweet & savory combination!

Spread it on toast, add it to your favorite snack, or enjoy it straight from the spoon!

👇 Would YOU try Bacon Peanut Butter?

🎃👻 IT’S A PEANUT BUTTER HALLOWEEN PARTY! 🥜🕷️No tricks, just delicious treats! 🍬Our Party Boxes are the perfect way to ad...
10/26/2026

🎃👻 IT’S A PEANUT BUTTER HALLOWEEN PARTY! 🥜🕷️

No tricks, just delicious treats! 🍬

Our Party Boxes are the perfect way to add a little sweetness to your Halloween celebrations!

🥜 5 delicious peanut butter flavors
🎃 Perfect for parties & gifting
👻 A spooky-good treat everyone will love!

Skip the candy and bring the peanut butter! 🧡🖤

🛍️ Grab your Party Box today!

🎃🍂 Fall is in the air, and so is the smell of freshly baked Pumpkin Loaves! 🍞🧡Soft, moist, and full of delicious pumpkin...
10/21/2026

🎃🍂 Fall is in the air, and so is the smell of freshly baked Pumpkin Loaves! 🍞🧡

Soft, moist, and full of delicious pumpkin spice flavor! These golden-brown loaves are the perfect fall treat to enjoy with your morning coffee or share with family and friends. ☕🍁

🍂 A little taste of fall in every bite!

🍂🥧 Fall is Here, and So Is Pecan Pie Season! Nothing says fall like the delicious smell of freshly baked pecan pie! 🤎Our...
10/16/2026

🍂🥧 Fall is Here, and So Is Pecan Pie Season!

Nothing says fall like the delicious smell of freshly baked pecan pie! 🤎

Our Pecan Pie Mix in a Jar makes baking your favorite fall dessert easier than ever!

🥧 Two Delicious Flavors:
🍁 Classic Pecan Pie – Sweet, rich, and full of pecan goodness!
🍫 Chocolate Pecan Pie – A chocolatey twist on a fall favorite!

✨ Just add eggs and butter, pour into a pie crust, and bake! It’s that EASY!

Perfect for fall gatherings, Thanksgiving desserts, holiday gifts, or simply treating yourself! 🍂

Two flavors. One easy dessert. Endless fall goodness! 🤎

🍓🥜 STRAWBERRY PEANUT BUTTER! 🍓🥜💕 Spread the Love! 💕Who says peanut butter has to be ordinary? Our Strawberry Peanut Butt...
10/13/2026

🍓🥜 STRAWBERRY PEANUT BUTTER! 🍓🥜

💕 Spread the Love! 💕

Who says peanut butter has to be ordinary? Our Strawberry Peanut Butter brings a deliciously sweet twist to a classic favorite!

🍓 Perfect on toast or bagels
🥜 Delicious in smoothies
🍓 A fun twist on your PB&J
🥄 Or enjoy it straight from the spoon!

One taste and you’ll be hooked! 😍

❤️ Sweet, nutty, and oh-so-delicious!

🍓 Have you tried our Strawberry Peanut Butter yet?

Address

615 E Moss Mill Road
Galloway, NJ
08205

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 5pm
Wednesday 11am - 5pm
Thursday 11am - 5pm
Friday 11am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 11am - 5pm

Telephone

+16096523928

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Smithville Peanut Butter Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Smithville Peanut Butter Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby grocery stores