Be Happy Pie Company

Call Directions Website

Be Happy Pie Company Be Happy Pie Company (West Side - Evansville, IN) is a full service bakery specializing in sweet and savory, made from scratch pies and more!

"Always made from scratch" is not just a motto - it is a testament to the purity and authenticity of our craft. At The Be Happy Pie Company, we're committed to using only the freshest, highest-quality ingredients because we believe that the best flavors are born from the best sources.

⏰THE CLOCK IS TICKING! You have just 5 HOURS LEFT to get your Thanksgiving pie pre-orders in! 🥧If you want a delicious, ...
11/18/2026

⏰THE CLOCK IS TICKING! You have just 5 HOURS LEFT to get your Thanksgiving pie pre-orders in! 🥧

If you want a delicious, made-from-scratch Be Happy Pie on your Thanksgiving table, TODAY IS YOUR LAST CHANCE! Our pre-orders close at 5 PM, and once the deadline passes, it’s too late to reserve your favorites.

📞 Call us, stop by, or order online before 5 PM TODAY! (Online ordering links in the comments)

🍒🥧TODAY IS YOUR LAST CHANCE!🥧🍒Thanksgiving is almost here, and today is the FINAL day to get your pie pre-orders in! Don...
11/18/2026

🍒🥧TODAY IS YOUR LAST CHANCE!🥧🍒

Thanksgiving is almost here, and today is the FINAL day to get your pie pre-orders in! Don’t leave dessert to chance or wait until it’s too late to get your favorites.

Let us take one thing off your Thanksgiving to-do list with a delicious, locally made, always-from-scratch pie!

📞 Call us, stop by, or place your order online TODAY before pre-orders close tonight! (Online ordering links in the comments)

Your Thanksgiving table deserves a little Be Happy!

🥧Evansville Thanksgiving Pre-Order Update!🍒A quick heads-up for our Evansville pie lovers: Chocolate Cream and Coconut C...
11/17/2026

🥧Evansville Thanksgiving Pre-Order Update!🍒

A quick heads-up for our Evansville pie lovers: Chocolate Cream and Coconut Cream are officially SOLD OUT for Thanksgiving pre-orders!

But don’t worry, there’s still PLENTY of deliciousness to choose from! We have lots of made-from-scratch favorites ready to make their way to your Thanksgiving table.

Don’t wait until the last minute to claim your favorites! Pre-orders close Wednesday, November 18.
📍 East & West Evansville
📞 Call, stop in, or order online!

11/17/2026
🍒🥧 A little reminder of the heart behind every pie: Be Happy Pie Company is locally owned, and everything we make is alw...
11/17/2026

🍒🥧 A little reminder of the heart behind every pie: Be Happy Pie Company is locally owned, and everything we make is always made from scratch!

Behind every pie is a team of hardworking hands, early mornings, and lots of love poured into making something special for your holiday table. ❤️Our bakery teams are working hard, baking up your favorites, and putting in the extra care to help make your Thanksgiving sweeter.

When you choose Be Happy Pie Company, you’re supporting a locally owned bakery and the people behind it. We’re so grateful to be part of your holiday traditions!

Make sure your Thanksgiving table has a little homemade happiness. Pre-order your pies today (Links in the comments below to pre-order online)🥧

🍒REMINDER🍒
11/17/2026

🍒REMINDER🍒

🎟️ Want FREE tickets to see Waitress at the Old National Events Plaza on December 5th?!

We’re giving you a chance to win! Stop by either our East or West Evansville Be Happy Pie Company locations and enter for your chance to score tickets to this incredible show!

A little bakery visit could turn into a big night out! ✨

Good luck, everyone!🥧

🍒EVANSVILLE🍒 Want FREE tickets?
11/17/2026

🍒EVANSVILLE🍒 Want FREE tickets?

🎟️ Want FREE tickets to see Waitress at the Old National Events Plaza on December 5th?!

We’re giving you a chance to win! Stop by either our East or West Evansville Be Happy Pie Company locations and enter for your chance to score tickets to this incredible show!

A little bakery visit could turn into a big night out! ✨

Good luck, everyone!🥧

⏰Thanksgiving pre-orders CLOSE this Wednesday, November 18, and the clock is ticking!Make Thanksgiving easier, skip the ...
11/16/2026

⏰Thanksgiving pre-orders CLOSE this Wednesday, November 18, and the clock is ticking!

Make Thanksgiving easier, skip the last-minute dessert scramble, and let us take care of the pie. ORDER YOUR THANKSGIVING PIES RIGHT NOW!

🍒 Evansville Online Ordering (double-check East or West pickup location):
https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus

📸Styling by: Julie Garcia

⏰ORDER NOW OR MISS OUT!🥧Thanksgiving pre-orders CLOSE this Wednesday, November 18, and the clock is ticking!Make Thanksg...
11/16/2026

⏰ORDER NOW OR MISS OUT!🥧

Thanksgiving pre-orders CLOSE this Wednesday, November 18, and the clock is ticking!

Make Thanksgiving easier, skip the last-minute dessert scramble, and let us take care of the pie. ORDER YOUR THANKSGIVING PIES RIGHT NOW!

🍒 Evansville Online Ordering (double-check East or West pickup location):
https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus

🍒 Kansas City Online Ordering:
https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanykc

📸Styling by: Julie Garcia

11/15/2026

⏰The countdown is ON!🥧

Thanksgiving is getting closer, and so is the deadline to get your favorite Be Happy pies! Wednesday, November 18, is the LAST DAY to place your Thanksgiving pre-orders. Don’t leave dessert to chance!

🍒Order online TODAY before time runs out!

🥧 Evansville Ordering (select East or West pickup):
https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus

🍒 Kansas City Ordering:
https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanykc

Your holiday table deserves a little Be Happy!

🥧Saturdays are sweeter with something made from scratch!🍒Your weekend treat is waiting! Stop by Be Happy Pie Company for...
11/14/2026

🥧Saturdays are sweeter with something made from scratch!🍒

Your weekend treat is waiting! Stop by Be Happy Pie Company for delicious sweet pies, savory favorites, and fresh-baked goodies.

📍 East Evansville — 6225 E. Virginia St., Suite C
📍 West Evansville — 2818 Mt. Vernon Ave., Suite B

🥧Saturdays are sweeter with something made from scratch!🍒Your weekend treat is waiting! Stop by Be Happy Pie Company for...
11/14/2026

🥧Saturdays are sweeter with something made from scratch!🍒

Your weekend treat is waiting! Stop by Be Happy Pie Company for delicious sweet pies, savory favorites, and fresh-baked goodies.

📍 East Evansville — 6225 E. Virginia St., Suite C
📍 West Evansville — 2818 Mt. Vernon Ave., Suite B
📍 Kansas City — 7506 N. Oak Trafficway, Suite 200, Gladstone, MO

🍒A little Be Happy spotlight this morning!🥧📺We were excited to have the opportunity to be featured on the 14 NEWS Mornin...
11/13/2026

🍒A little Be Happy spotlight this morning!🥧📺

We were excited to have the opportunity to be featured on the 14 NEWS Morning Show, showcasing our delicious, made-from-scratch pies and the incredible team behind them!

ALSO: Our Social Media Manager, Ashleigh Culiver, had the opportunity to present at the Evansville Regional Economic Partnership CNN networking this morning, sharing more about Be Happy Pie Company and our work in the community.

We love opportunities to share what makes Be Happy special, and most importantly, we’d love to be part of your Thanksgiving table! ❤️

Thanksgiving pie pre-orders close November 18! Don’t wait until the last slice of opportunity is gone. Stop in, call, or order online to reserve your holiday favorites.

Evansville Online Ordering (reminder to double check your pickup location East or West): https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus

Kansas City Online Ordering: https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanykc

Huge thank you to Evansville Regional Economic Partnership for the opportunity to present to such an awesome group!
11/13/2026

Huge thank you to Evansville Regional Economic Partnership for the opportunity to present to such an awesome group!

🍒🥧Your window of opportunity for a delicious, made-from-scratch pie is closing! Thanksgiving pre-orders close Wednesday,...
11/13/2026

🍒🥧Your window of opportunity for a delicious, made-from-scratch pie is closing! Thanksgiving pre-orders close Wednesday, November 18, and you don’t want to miss out on your favorite pie for the holiday table.

📞 Call us, stop in, or pre-order online TODAY to secure your Thanksgiving pies before the deadline!

Evansville Online Ordering (reminder to double check your pickup location East or West): https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus

Kansas City Online Ordering: https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanykc

Let’s make your Thanksgiving a little sweeter.

Your Thanksgiving pie could come with a little extra magic! 🎟️🥧When you pre-order your Thanksgiving pies, you’re automat...
11/12/2026

Your Thanksgiving pie could come with a little extra magic! 🎟️🥧

When you pre-order your Thanksgiving pies, you’re automatically entered into our Golden Ticket Giveaway for a chance to WIN a FREE 10” pie!

Pre-orders close November 18th.

11/12/2026

A Thanksgiving table just isn’t complete without pie!🥧

Make room for your Be Happy Pie Company favorites this Thanksgiving and let us bring a little extra joy to your holiday gathering! Don’t forget to pre-order your pies by November 18th at 5 PM to make sure dessert is covered.

Evansville Online Ordering (reminder to double check your pickup location East or West): https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanyus
Kansas City Online Ordering: https://cash.app/$behappypiecompanykc

📸Styling by: Julie Garcia

West Side, your next pie run is calling! 🥧We’ve been busy baking, and there’s plenty of goodness ready to go in our case...
11/11/2026

West Side, your next pie run is calling! 🥧We’ve been busy baking, and there’s plenty of goodness ready to go in our case.

From sweet treats to savory favorites, full-size pies to 5” pies and pie bites, there’s lots to choose from. Stop in, take a look, and find something delicious to bring home!

And don’t put off those Thanksgiving plans! Pre-orders close November 18th at 5 PM. Get your holiday pies reserved now so you can check dessert off your list!

We’ll see you at the bakery, we are open until 5pm!
📍 2818 Mt. Vernon Ave., Suite B, Evansville

Address

2818 Mount Vernon Avenue, Suite B
Evansville, IN
47712

Opening Hours

Tuesday 7:30am - 5pm
Wednesday 7:30am - 5pm
Thursday 7:30am - 5pm
Friday 7:30am - 5pm
Saturday 8am - 12pm

Telephone

+18124497718

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Be Happy Pie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share

Nearby grocery stores