Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza

Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza I’m Mike (Bro. Yoder). I’m formerly Amish. I grew up in a home where great homemade cooking & baking was the everyday norm. Even PIZZA!

I’m fulfilling a dream of opening a pizza shop. I guarantee you fresh homemade dough and ingredients every time!

06/18/2026

Just took the last two trays out of the oven & frosted them with my homemade vanilla buttercream!!
😋😋😋
First come - first served!!

Hi Everyone!Don’t forget!… pre-orders are NO LONGER NECESSARY!!😊 Except when ordering 10+ rolls, which only requires 1 d...
06/18/2026

Hi Everyone!

Don’t forget!… pre-orders are NO LONGER NECESSARY!!😊 Except when ordering 10+ rolls, which only requires 1 day advance notice.😊

My Amish Cinnamon Rolls are every Wednesday thru Sunday, 9AM - till out of dough! So come early!
[Maple will still only be Saturdays & Sundays, with a limited supply].

Hope to see you soon!

❤️Bro Yoder

06/17/2026

[SOLD OUT!]

Heads up!… the last two trays of cinnamon rolls just came out of the oven!, and all the dough is gone [for today!].

The “no preorder” approach went VERY smoothly today. Hot rolls came out of the oven about every 90 minutes, putting big smiles on everyone’s happy faces!😊

Hope to bake for you soon, by the wonderful grace of God!

❤️Bro Yoder

Hi Everyone!REMINDER….Tomorrow (Wednesday June 17) starts our “no pre-order needed” program. I’ll have a certain number ...
06/17/2026

Hi Everyone!

REMINDER….

Tomorrow (Wednesday June 17) starts our “no pre-order needed” program. I’ll have a certain number of cinnamon rolls (200-250 for the day) available every 90 minutes for sale, until the days’ dough runs out!!😊 If I need to make more dough next week to meet demand, I will! Please bear with me as we go through the new “no pre-order” approach.🙏

Hope to see you soon!

❤️Bro Yoder

06/16/2026

Hi Everyone!

Monday 6/15, 8:35pm…

**** Important News ****

STARTING THIS WEEK THERE IS NO LONGER A NEED TO “PRE-ORDER” MY AMISH CINNAMON ROLLS!
I’LL BE BAKING HUNDREDS OF ROLLS THROUGHOUT THE DAY (about every 90 minutes), UNTIL SOLD OUT. First come, first served. Walk-ins welcome!

NOTE! If you want 10 or more rolls then you will [still] need to pre-order either the day before, or the morning of they are wanted. For that, just send me a DM here as I’ve been doing.

**** A HUGE THANK YOU TO EVERYONE FOR YOUR KINDNESS AND LOVING MY AMISH CINNAMON ROLLS!!!❤️

Hope to bake for you soon!!

❤️Bro Yoder

06/14/2026

[SOLD OUT]

Extra rolls are boxed and ready for pick up! First come, first served!

Hi Everyone!Friday evening, 6/12, 9:50pm….Just got home from the bakery from making big batches of my special Amish Cinn...
06/13/2026

Hi Everyone!

Friday evening, 6/12, 9:50pm….

Just got home from the bakery from making big batches of my special Amish Cinnamon Roll dough for tomorrow.😊

REMINDER…. I WILL HAVE MY ORIGINAL “BRO YODER” MAPLE FROSTING TOMORROW AND SUNDAY!! - and every Saturday & Sunday going forward. If you love Maple rolls, you’ll definitely LOVE THIS!!!😊 BUT, for now, I’m only making a set number of trays.
You can DM me or call the store to check availability. (814) 838-2113

Of course my Bro Yoder vanilla buttercream frosting is always here!

Hope to bake for you soon- by the grace of God….

❤️Bro Yoder

06/12/2026

[UPDATE] SOLD OUT FOR THE DAY. SEE YOU TOMORROW!
We open at 9AM. Might earlier soon. I’ll let you know.
We got a great mojo going with the big new oven!😊
————-

I baked some “Extra Rolls” today!!!😊
First come, first served!!

Good Friday Morning Everyone!6/12, 7:20AM…I’ll have my Amish Cinnamon Rolls ready at 9AM for BOTH walk-ins and pre-order...
06/12/2026

Good Friday Morning Everyone!

6/12, 7:20AM…

I’ll have my Amish Cinnamon Rolls ready at 9AM for BOTH walk-ins and pre-orders!!! 😊
But if you’re wanting 10 or more, you need to order at least 3 HOURS ahead.🙏 Just call the store: 814-838-2113.

❤️Bro Yoder

Hi Everyone!Tuesday 6/9, 7:45PM…I’m still taking pre-orders for this week, but also will be baking extras for walk-ins!!...
06/10/2026

Hi Everyone!

Tuesday 6/9, 7:45PM…

I’m still taking pre-orders for this week, but also will be baking extras for walk-ins!! I’m getting closer to having them constantly available all day long Wednesdays thru Sundays, until sold out.
It’ll take a bit of time to figure out the baking schedule - as I want my rolls to be as fresh as possible for you!
I’m all about freshness and wholesome-ness!!😊

Also, today I baked 12 dozen of my very popular homemade sugar sprinkled peanut butter cookies. Already selling quick! Stop in for a bag of 4 for only $5! You won’t be disappointed!

Hope to bake for you soon, by the grace of God!

❤️Bro Yoder

Address

3108 W Lake Road
Erie, PA

Telephone

+18148382113

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bro. Yoder’s Authentic Italian-Style Pizza posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category