Grocery stores in Shelter Island, NY

Home
United States
Shelter Island

Town in Suffolk County, New York

Compare supermarkets, grocery stores and food shops in Shelter Island.

Want your business to be the top-listed grocery store in Shelter Island, NY?

Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Shelter Island IGA

A

Shelter Island IGA

75 N Ferry Road, Shelter Island 11964

Supermarket

Call Directions

Elli's Country Store

B

Elli's Country Store

35 S Ferry Road, Shelter Island 11964

Deli

Call Directions

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

C

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

41 Smith Street, Shelter Island 11964

Fish Market

Call Directions

Greeny's Natural Food Market

D

Greeny's Natural Food Market

Shelter Island 11964

Grocers

Call Directions

E

Eagle Deli

25 W Neck Road, Shelter Island 11965

Grocers

Call Directions

Vine Street Café Market

F

Vine Street Café Market

41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island 11964

Speciality Food Shop

Call Directions

Table of Content General Store

G

Table of Content General Store

Shelter Island 11964

Grocers

Call Directions

Supermarkets and grocery stores

Fresh produce, butchers and markets

Fish Markets

Delis, cheese and specialty food

Show all categories

Nearby grocery stores